Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Computational Limericks

This was a very interesting article. The article begins by stating what us as readers might be thinking, which is “ why is this relevant”. Lessard and Levison stated that limericks represent the stage between puns and jokes. In short, unlike crass jokes, these jokes have a loose structure. We are then given three models of limericks.

The first of these is exhaustive generation. The text was a little unclear as to what this entails, but I gathered that this is writing whatever you are thinking, no matter how senseless. I assume that this can clear ones’ mind, and also give a bank of ideas to go back to. The next step is production, followed by backtracking and editing, restricted by a set of rules. The third is multiple constraint satisfaction.. This , as the article states, “ is the production of a text that obeys multiple constraints”.

After we are given a summary of the rules that govern a limerick, we get an explanation of what a limerick actually is. I would rather have this come before the specifics, but I digress. For those that don’t know, ( and trust me, I was a part of this group before I read this article) a limerick is a 5 line poem that is generally humorous. The poem has an aabba rhyme scheme, and lines 1, 2 and 5 have 9 syllables. Lines 3 and 4 have six syllables.

The articles talks in detail about how the limerick is dictated by the rhyme scheme, which I found to be interesting. Obviously any type of set rhyme scheme is self restricting, and it is this restriction that ironically can bring out some pretty creative limericks. As the article states, this rhyme scheme sets about a right to left approach of writing the lyric, where the writer may choose the word that will rhyme first, and then base the rest of the line off of that word. When the Limerick begins, the writer sometimes chooses to make a skeleton of the overall poem. For example, If I was writing one, and was including my name, I would try and compose a list of words that rhyme with Zach ( quack, sack, rack, tack, etc).

The article talks about how most limericks have some lexical similarities within the poem. For example, many of the words could be dealing with the same topic. The example we are given is food preparation, with many of the words having to deal with this topic ( the limerick contains the words roasted, boiled, baked, toasted, stewed). Also there is such a thing as a historical limerick, which generally follows a certain plot structure, if you will. A limerick about the crashing of the Hindenburg would start out with the motivation, the act, the factor that made it crash, and the consequences.

Limericks also deal with a great bit of wordplay. Generally the sound of the word is very important. For example, we are given a limerick about a dog that plays a musical instrument and keeps thieves away. Given its relation to music, we see some clever wordplay on the word bark. Almost anyone vaguely familiar with music knows of Bach, so the limerick states at the end” For its Bach was much worse than its Bite”. All in all, I found this article to be interesting because I didn’t realize that something so seemingly simple could have such complexity.

22 comments:

amurphy said...

I think having a computer program which makes the limerick for you takes all the creativity out of making your own limerick. My group had a fun time making our limerick. I don't think we would have had the same experience if we had done it with a computer program.

Amanda Yates said...

I think Limericks is a creative and fun way to learn how to write poetry.

MikeS said...

The great thing about limericks is that you have to think in order to make your thoughts fit the structure. This makes the thoughts you come up with seem more impressive. Just like Haiku, limericks show a greater engagement of the mind during the writing process.

Regina said...

I think limericks are fun. They say so much in just a few lines.

LIGurl said...

This was an interesting (and long) blog post. I think the whole topic of limericks is very interesting. I enjoyed writing the limerick with my group. The reading was interesting. I had no idea that someone could write so much and be so analytical about something so small and silly as as a limerick. Most limericks are silly and sometimes have mean or sexual connotations. This article kind of got down to the nitty gritty of limericks. It was very interesting to read

anrome09 said...

I liked the article and I had fun making my own limerick. I think it is neat that you can just put a few words that rhyme together in a 5 line poem and make a really funny story. I think that having a computer that would make the limerick may take out of the owners creativity, but a think if it just gave you words that rhymed together then it would expand the limericks because it would be easier to make them.

vknepp5 said...

I think limericks are fun! It is harder to do than it looks --- to keep the rhythm and rhyme... They are pretty funny! I did not know that computers could create poems!!!

Lindsay said...

I liked the exercise using limericks. I think that it is a fun idea for students to be able to do while also being creative.

Bonnie Bilyeu said...

I definitely think that a computer program which makes the limerick for you is not a good idea. If you are too lazy to write your own limerick, then don't.

Jessica said...

The limerick assignment was pretty interesting and a lot of fun. Computer programs would not be the same as a human creating the limerick because the computer would not have the intelligence to create some of the puns that a human could think of. Computers are pretty nice, but I do not think they would be able to take over the creating aspect of poetry and limericks. It would just not be the same.

Amy Mckenzie said...

I think that having a website that matches rhyming words together makes this assignment much more easier. But by doing so, you lose the creativity involved. Also, the computer program that writes Limericks for you seems a little silly and takes all the fun out of writing.

Jim Radice said...

I am surprised that there are so many different facets to limericks as a whole. Both in the number of rules governing a limerick, and the different uses for them. I had never heard of a historical limerick before, and i found that interesting.

D.Colcord said...

I actually prefer poems that rhyme, and limericks tend be just fun humorous poems. limericks are fun poems, and how many poems can you say that about? Acomputer program creating limericks just seems blah to me. Using a computer would just take all the fun and creativity out of it.

Tierra said...

I think that limericks are interesting and fun because it makes it more interesting to read and keep the audience wanting to read more.

AGholson said...

Limericks can provide useful ways for young children especially to learn a variety of things. I think that this assignment was fun and could be used inside the classroom.

christian holt said...

I don't think it's a good idea to have computer programs that do everything for us. Why would it be necessary to have programs that do things like make limericks? That's kind of ridiculous. I loved making ours up.

Stephanie Tillery said...

This article was interesting. I don't think that a computer could every great a good limerick. I'm sure that a computer could create a limerick, but it would not have any humor or emotion in it. I enjoyed making my own limerick. I think they are fun to make and it helps me work on my creativity skills.

bnorbut said...

Poetry is supposed to be about self expression. If a computer does it, what is the point? That sounds like letting a computer put together notes and then calling it a song. It would be interesting but it misses the point.
Bryan Norbut

awetz86 said...

I enjoyed making a Limerick eventhough it took a second time to get it right. I feel poetry is not used often as it should be in the classroom. Also, it allows students to write poetry in a creative way!

Josie! said...

I think that a computer program that writes a limerick for you is pointless. If you want to write something you should do it yourself and not have a computer program do it for you.

Anonymous said...

I thought this passage about limericks was very informative. Before this article summary I did not know what limericks were. After reading about the rhyme sceme, style, etc of limericks I am not to fond of them. I am a poet and although limericks serve many purposes I do not consider them to be artistic writing.

zach said...

Zach, this is probably the greatest blog post ever. Wait.. I might be a little biased...